Summary: The U.S. housing market is undergoing a profound shift as buyers abandon the traditional “starter home” path in favor of “forever” homes that serve multiple generations. First-time buyers now average 40 years old—the oldest on record—and are skipping entry-level properties entirely. This article explores how remote work, multigenerational living, affordability pressures, and new policies are reshaping what Americans want from homeownership and how the market is responding.
The End of the Starter Home Era
The traditional path to homeownership—buy a modest starter home, build equity, and upgrade every five to seven years—is becoming obsolete. Today’s buyers are rejecting this model in overwhelming numbers. Fifty-eight percent of non-homeowners say buying a starter home and upgrading later simply “makes no sense these days” . This sentiment is driving one of the most significant shifts in American housing behavior in decades.
What’s replacing the starter home is what industry professionals call the “right-now home”—a strategic purchase that fits today’s life while offering flexibility for tomorrow . But the more dramatic trend is the surge in buyers skipping starter homes entirely and purchasing properties designed for the long haul. Nearly three in four prospective buyers expect their first home to be their forever home, a view shared by 67% of house-hunting Millennials .
The data tells a stark story. First-time buyers now account for just 21% of the market—a record low—and their average age has reached 40, up from 38 last year and a dramatic leap from 28 in the early 1990s . A delayed start means lost equity. According to NAR Executive Vice President Shannon McGahn, “Delayed or denied homeownership until age 40, instead of 30, can mean losing roughly $150,000 in equity on a typical starter home” .
The Rise of the Multipurpose Home
The pandemic permanently altered how Americans view their living spaces. Homes are no longer just places to sleep and eat; they are offices, schools, gyms, and multigenerational hubs. This shift has fundamentally changed what buyers prioritize.
Remote Work Reshapes Demand
Before 2020, commute distance dictated most housing decisions. Today, flexibility in where and how people work has reshaped buyer priorities. The number of Americans working primarily from home more than tripled between 2019 and 2021, and this continues to influence housing decisions nationwide .
Buyers are now hyper-focused on how a home functions day-to-day. Dedicated office space, flexible layouts, and rooms that can adapt as routines change have become essential. This shift has breathed new life into older suburban homes with larger footprints and the potential for renovations .
Multigenerational Living Takes Hold
Economic pressures are bringing families back together under one roof. Caregiving responsibilities, high childcare costs, and the rising cost of living are driving a resurgence in multigenerational living arrangements.
The numbers are striking:
- 66% of Millennial homeowners and 75% of Gen Z homeowners say it was important to buy a home that could eventually accommodate parents or grandparents .
- 54% of Millennials and 41% of Gen Z identify as part of the “sandwich generation”—caring for both children and aging parents .
- 60% of Gen Z and Millennial homeowners plan to invest in additional space to generate rental income, either through long-term tenants or short-term rentals .
Families are pooling resources to purchase properties large enough for extended family. Older suburban homes on bigger lots are enjoying a renaissance as buyers seek space for home offices, granny flats, and gardens . These properties offer families the opportunity to grow and change over many years without having to move .
Policy Shifts: Limiting Wall Street’s Role
Government action is also reshaping the market landscape. In January 2026, President Trump signed an Executive Order aimed at preventing large institutional investors from buying single-family homes that could otherwise be purchased by families .
The Order directs federal agencies to:
- Prevent Federal programs from facilitating sales of single-family homes to institutional investors
- Promote sales to individual owner-occupants through “first-look” policies
- Review anti-competitive practices by institutional investors in the single-family rental market
This policy responds to growing public frustration. Institutional buyers with vast resources have been outbidding families, turning neighborhoods into investor rental portfolios instead of communities . However, the order carves out exemptions for build-to-rent communities, where firms construct new neighborhoods specifically for rental, a distinction that preserves a growing housing supply channel .
Changing Attitudes Toward Buying vs. Renting
Despite persistent affordability challenges, Americans are once again favoring homeownership over renting. A May 2026 Bank of America survey found that 53% of respondents now say it’s better to buy, the first time sentiment has favored buying since 2023 .
Key shifts in sentiment include:
- 90% say a home is a valuable investment, up from 79% in 2025
- 94% say homeownership provides stability, up from 83% in 2025
- 32% say they are more confident in their ability to buy a home this year, up from 27% last year
Prospective buyers appear less willing to wait for conditions to improve. The percentage waiting for prices and rates to fall dropped from 75% in 2025 to 71% in 2026, with Gen Z and Millennials leading the shift . “We are seeing meaningful changes in attitudes toward homeownership,” said Matt Vernon, Head of Consumer Lending at Bank of America. “Despite real and persistent challenges in the market, buyers and owners are increasingly optimistic, and many are starting to move forward rather than waiting on the sidelines” .
Energy Efficiency Becomes a Priority
With costs top of mind, buyers are prioritizing homes that save money over the long term. Energy efficiency was the dominant priority for consumers throughout 2023, 2024, and 2025, outperforming other desirable housing attributes .
Interest in smaller homes rose from 28% to 38% in 2025, reinforcing a broader market move away from square footage as the primary indicator of value. “Affordability and operational cost savings are increasingly driving decision-making” . Builders that offer right-sized, high-performance homes emphasizing energy efficiency will appeal to today’s buyers, especially when these features are positioned as foundational to affordability rather than premium add-ons .
The Rise of AI in Homebuying
Technology is transforming how Americans approach homeownership. One in five prospective buyers (20%) used AI tools or chatbots in the past year for homebuying research, including 28% of Millennials and 32% of Gen Z .
Top AI use cases include:
- Estimating affordability, mortgage payments, or closing costs (57%)
- General education and research about the process (55%)
- Researching neighborhoods, market trends, or property values (52%)
However, buyers still prefer human expertise for key steps such as touring homes (55%) and legal advice (54%). “AI is becoming a meaningful first step in the homebuying journey, especially for younger buyers,” says Vernon. “However, when it comes to high-stakes decisions, people still want trusted experts by their side” .
A Market in Transition
The American housing market is not broken—it is evolving. The shift away from starter homes, the rise of multigenerational living, and the growing prioritization of energy efficiency all reflect a market responding to economic pressures and lifestyle changes.
For buyers, this means rethinking traditional assumptions. The forever home is no longer something you grow into over decades; increasingly, it’s where you start. For sellers and builders, the message is clear: homes that accommodate work, family, and aging parents—efficiently and affordably—are the new gold standard.
Adapting to the New Priorities
- Buyers are planning for the long haul. With first-time buyers now averaging 40 years old, many are skipping starter homes in favor of properties designed to serve multiple life stages.
- Multigenerational living is reshaping the market. Nearly 75% of young homeowners want homes that can accommodate aging parents. Homes with flexible layouts and potential for in-law suites are increasingly in demand.
- Energy efficiency is a top priority. Buyers are seeking smaller, more efficient homes that reduce long-term operating costs, reflecting a broader shift toward value-driven decisions.
- Policy is limiting institutional investors. New executive orders restrict large investors from buying single-family homes, potentially freeing up inventory for individual buyers.
- AI is becoming a standard research tool. While buyers still want human expertise for major decisions, AI is increasingly used for cost estimation, market research, and education.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Why are first-time buyers getting older?
The average first-time buyer is now 40, up from 28 in the 1990s. High home prices, elevated interest rates, and student debt have delayed homeownership for many. The NAR estimates that delayed purchase until age 40 versus 30 can cost roughly $150,000 in lost equity on a typical starter home .
2. Are starter homes disappearing?
Nearly 58% of non-homeowners say buying a starter home and upgrading later “makes no sense these days.” Buyers are increasingly purchasing properties designed as forever homes from the start, driven by high transaction costs and the desire to avoid multiple moves .
3. What’s driving multigenerational living trends?
Caregiving pressures, high childcare costs, and the rising cost of living are bringing families back together. Nearly 75% of Millennial and Gen Z homeowners want homes that can accommodate parents or grandparents .
4. How is remote work changing housing demand?
Remote work has reduced the importance of commute distance and increased demand for homes with dedicated office space and flexible layouts. Buyers are more willing to move to affordable areas if they can work remotely .
5. Is the government limiting corporate buyers?
Yes. In January 2026, an executive order was signed to prevent federal programs from facilitating sales of single-family homes to large institutional investors, promoting sales to individual owner-occupants through first-look policies .
6. What is the “build-to-rent” exemption?
While the executive order restricts institutional investors from buying existing homes, it exempts build-to-rent communities where firms construct new neighborhoods specifically for rental, encouraging housing supply growth .
7. Are Americans more optimistic about buying homes?
Yes. In May 2026, 53% of Americans said it’s better to buy than rent, the first time sentiment has favored buying since 2023. Additionally, 90% say a home is a valuable investment, up from 79% in 2025 .
8. How important is energy efficiency to today’s buyers?
Energy efficiency was the dominant priority for consumers throughout 2023-2025, outperforming other desirable housing attributes. Smaller homes and solar power have also grown in importance as buyers focus on operational cost savings .
9. Are younger buyers using AI for home searches?
Yes. One in five prospective buyers used AI tools in the past year for homebuying research, including 28% of Millennials and 32% of Gen Z. Top uses include estimating costs and researching neighborhoods .
10. Are buyers willing to compromise to afford a home?
Yes. 76% of prospective buyers would consider a more affordable area even if it meant paying a higher interest rate, and 71% would consider a move for a better location .
About the Author
